Barefoot Shoes: Fad or Functional?
92What the Heck are these Barefoot Shoes?
I'm a runner. In fact, I train for marathons year-round and I've seen and worn my share of running shoes.
But I'm just not sure about the latest "fad" in footwear. Barefoot shoes are funny looking, but people who wear them swear they are exceptionally functional and better for their overall fitness level and health. The minimalist shoes are sweeping the running circuit and even creating converts who wear them during cycling, hiking, climbing and aerobic exercise classes.
Barefoot running shoes are extremely flat and include five "fingers" in which your toes fit like a glove. They are meant to provide protection for the soles of your feet, while strengthening the muscles in your foot, toes, ankles and calves. Barefoot shoes claim to change your running stride to become more natural, once you remove all the carefully constructed padding, air and high tech soles that athletic shoe manufacturers have worked to develop over the past 30 years.
Not to mention, they're extremely ugly. But do they work?
About Barefoot Shoes
The term "barefoot shoes" is a bit of an oxymoron, admittedly. After all, if you are barefoot, your feet are bare. No shoes. No coverings whatsoever.
Yet, our urban environment doesn't allow the type of free running and walking enjoyed by our ancestors. The thin covering provided by barefoot shoes is for protection of the soles and tops of your feet. But they are designed to be minimalist so that your feet function as they would if you were, in fact, barefoot.
With only a few millimeters of a thin rubber sole separating your tender arches from the pavement, barefoot shoes are an amazingly light 6 ounces in weight. Simply put, barefoot shoes do nothing more than cover your feet. There is no arch support, no cushioning, no "air," nada.
But isn't this a total 180 from the highly engineered running shoes to which we've become accustomed over the past 20-30 years?
Do barefoot shoes really work, or are they just the latest "getting back to nature" fad invented by some hippy green guy?
The answers appear to be yes, yes and yes!
The original "barefoot shoes" are the Vibram FiveFingers, created by Industrial Designer, Robert Fliri and Marco Bramani, the grandson of Vitale Bramani, who invented the first rubber soles for mountaineering boots in 1935. The two men took the idea of barefoot shoes to Tony Post, who was a former collegiate runner. Post is now the president and CEO of Virbram USA.
Although barefoot shoes were originally designed for people enjoying sailing and climbing as an alternative to going completely barefoot, runners quickly picked up the invention as a revolutionary way to enjoy the sport and reduce injury and pain. They've become so hot over the past few years that Time Magazine named them as one of the best inventions in 2007.
The Inventor of the Barefoot Running Shoe
|
|
VIBRAM FIVE FINGERS MENS BIKILA - GREY/RED/GREY - 42
Current Bid: $69.99
|
|
|
VIBRAM FIVE FINGERS MEN'S SHOES KOMODOSPORT SIZE 40-43
Current Bid: $68.61
|
|
|
Vibram FiveFingers -- Men's KSO (M148 & M146C)
Current Bid: $69.95
|
|
|
Vibram FiveFingers -- Men's KSO (M148 & M146C)
Current Bid: $69.95
|
|
|
Vibram FiveFingers -- Men's KSO (M148 & M146C)
Current Bid: $69.95
|
|
|
Vibram FiveFingers -- Men's KSO (M148 & M146C)
Current Bid: $69.95
|
How do Barefoot Shoes Work?
Wearing barefoot shoes are said to return our gait to a natural state. Our leg and foot muscles can actually get stronger so they can support knees, and even reduce back and hip pain. Not only that, but barefoot shoes can help improve agility, balance and posture.
According to the Vibram FiveFingers website:
The typical human foot is an anatomical marvel of evolution with 26 bones, 33 joints, 20 muscles and hundreds of sensory receptors, tendons and ligaments. Like the rest of the body, to keep our feet healthy, they need to be stimulated and exercised.
Unlike traditional running shoes, barefoot shoes allow your foot to hit the ground as if you had no shoes on - naturally. Instead of a heelstrike, you'll land on the ball of your foot. This simple motion will completely change the biomechanics of your run.
For some people the change in gait and biomechanics is too much. Experts often recommend that you wear the shoes for short periods of time to begin with before gradually working your way up. As you do so, you develop new muscles that have probably not been used before during your running. It might take weeks, or months, before you can comfortably run in the barefoot shoes.
Those that have made the transition usually swear by the shoes.
The Mechanics of Running in Vibram FiveFinger Barefoot Shoes
Pros and Cons of Barefoot Shoes
Pros
| Cons
|
|---|---|
Allows for proper biomechanics in walking and running
| It can take time to adjust and the shoes are not usually recommended for long distance
|
Fits like a glove - almost like being barefoot
| People that need orthotics, those that over-pronoate, with extremely flat feet, or webbed toes should not wear them
|
Comes in many colors and styles
| Still pretty ugly!
|
Cost ranges from $80-125
| Considered to be less durable than running shoes
|
Likely to find bargains on them on eBay or Craigslist
| You may wonder why people are selling their barefoot shoes
|
Learn How to Run in Barefoot Shoes
Do I Wear Barefoot Shoes?
As for me, I'm sticking with my running shoes for now. I'm not ready to go barefoot running. In fact, the barefoot shoes are not recommended for long distances like the marathon (for which I am currently training).
The owner of one of the local running stores in my hometown states that, generally speaking, people use barefoot shoes to complement rather than replace their traditional running shoes.
So, maybe one day, I'll try a pair of barefoot shoes for my strength class or even spin. Perhaps I'll wear them on a hike in the mountains nearby.
- Introducing the Nissan LEAF Electric Car
The Nissan Leaf is one of the first 100% electric cars that is commercially produced and available to drivers now! - 17 months ago
- Google eBooks for Your eReader, Computer and More!
Google ebooks may be an alternative to other electronic book readers. - 17 months ago
- Holiday Coffee Cake Recipe
Coffee cake recipes like this are easy and delicious. - 19 months ago
- Eco-friendly Candles for Healthy Home Ambiance
Eco-friendly candles burn cleaner, to enhance the ambiance in your home without toxic fumes, lead-based wicks or paraffin wax. - 19 months ago
- Palm Desert, California: A Kid-Friendly Vacation in Southern Calfornia
What to see and do on a family vacation in Palm Desert California - 20 months ago
- Visit the Oregon Coast: a Pet-Friendly Vacation
The Oregon Coast has a number of properties that allow and encourage you to bring your pets. - 20 months ago
- The High Desert Museum in Central Oregon
The High Desert Museum in Central Oregon is a zoo, history museum and has exciting, rotating collections. - 20 months ago
- Tour the Cascade Lakes Highway in Central Oregon (Photography Tour)
The Cascade Lakes Highway in Central Oregon takes you past Mt. - 20 months ago
More Hubs by this Author
- Self Driving Cars: Robotic Cars to Improve Safety and Fuel Efficiency on the Road
Can you imagine riding in a 100% robotic, self-driving car? - 2 days ago
- Signs and Symptoms of High Blood Sugar (Hyperglycemia)
Untreated, high blood sugar - also known as hyperglycemia - is a dangerous health risk. - 4 days ago
- Best Workout Routines to Lose Weight After Pregnancy
If you have recently had a baby and you are looking for a workout routine to help you lose weight, consider the suggestions in this article. - 9 days ago
- Kids Cook Monday: Garlic Shrimp and Rice Recipe
Shrimp is a low-fat healthy ingredient in this delicious recipe. - 13 days ago
- How to Prepare a Useful Self-Evaluation: Get a Raise or Promotion
Writing a self-evaluation is an important tool for a company to assess your performance and show your superiors that you should be awarded a raise or promotion. - 2 weeks ago
- Tips on Getting Solar Panels for Your Home
If you are considering installing solar panels on your property, think about these factors. - 3 weeks ago
- Running Marathons and Other Races with Insulin Dependent Diabetes
Training for a marathon or other endurance race can be challenging if you have insulin dependent diabetes. - 4 weeks ago
- 10 Creative Solar Energy Applications
Solar power can be used for more than just generating residential electricity. - 5 weeks ago
Would You Wear Barefoot Shoes for Athletic Training?
See results without votingHave Something to Say?
Did you enjoy this article? If so, please leave me a comment below and tell me what you liked best!
For more information about the author, Stephhicks68, please visit my profile page here on HubPages.
Want to join in the fun and publish here too? Why not sign up here? Its FREE!
vote upvote downshareprintflag
- Useful (21)
- Funny (2)
- Awesome (5)
- Beautiful
- Interesting (5)
CommentsLoading...
Hm.
My wife, the runner, hates wearing shoes. Maybe she'd like these.
Thanks Steph!
You have a great article here. I would like them. If I am home I never wear shoes. I only don't wear shoes at home. Every other place I am in shoes are flip flops mostly. I live in Florida, we live in flip flops here. I have seen these shoes around. I think there awesome. Voted up.
Sweet wishes Rhonda
Hi, Steph. So, good Hub. Coincidentally, I just purchased a pair of the Vibram Five Fingers yesterday. This comes after outwardly making fun of them, and those who wear them, for the last year. Why the "flip-flop?" I'm 33, and have been doing a lot more running, soccer, and basketball playing. The ole shock absorbers (knees) and lower back don't feel as good as they used to. I know several guys who are bigger than me and have had issues with their knees and backs and swear by them. I figured it was time to give them a try. However, and I caution here, with any new technology, one should "tread lightly" when breaking new ground. I did a mile on the tread mill yesterday and will only do 1-2 miles a few days a week with them until I am comfortable. It does feel different, as expected, but until my feet are more acclimated I will only be doing my longer runs with trainers.
I dunno. I don't run. Years and years ago, when I was younger and still able to run, a chiropractor I had at the time told me running and jogging are the single worst things you can do to your spine, as the compression and pounding transmits up your spinal column to the tune of a couple of hundred pounds per square inch!
Even though I'm not a physicist--I did learn a physics principle while in a bowling league. That is this: an object in motion gains 6 times its weight. So, your 10-pound bowling ball hits the pins with an effective force of a 60 pound object!
Ergo, multiply your weight by 6 to find out how much force is transmitted up your spine. (It might be minimized some if running on a flexible surface with 'give' like dry beach sand or grass.)
I have a problem with shoes especially my right foot.. I don't know if these would work or not, but I might take a look. However they do look ugly to me.
Stephhicks68,
I don't know, I havn't gone barefoot since I was a kid. I don't know if I would really like it anymore. I did recently hear a second hand story about someone seeing a guy running in the middle of winter..... and strangly enough, he was completely barefoot! Now that I read this, I think maybe its some kind of fad, or something, ... Who knew! Doubt I would ever try it..... but who knows..
I've been having trouble with my knees (one more than the other) for a couple of years, Steph, and I just bought a pair of Nike Frees to experiment with a more barefoot-like running shoe. If my knees start to improve, I'd consider switching to the Vibram shoes. I'll let you know!
I have problems with my back due to two ops and I am wondering if these would be any good. Mind you I don't really like the look of them.
Thanks for sharing this hub, well written and plenty of info.
wow.. I hadn't even heard of these.. I love going barefoot but I'm not sure how these would feel between my toes...worth a try I guess. Great informative hub, thank you!
"Bare footin..." Let us know as you progress...
They are very funny looking. Not everything is for everybody but the best way to find out if they will work for you is to try them. After all, we went from plain old tennis shoes to naming a shoe for each sport and they all go through transitions for better this and more of that.
Nice sales pitch, but if you're not gonna try them, neither am I. Plus, how much do these little creepy things cost? expensive? How would I look in em? would I scare the neighbor's dogs? If I find them in a store near me, will I be laughing? crying? I think I'll be afraid to be seen in them. but maybe not! Maybe someone will pay me to wear a pair! They look like they'd be hell on pavement, also.
Both of my sons and husband are runners. One son loves them and doesn't wear anything else the other one wears them on dirt tracks but not cement.
I don't run but walk and prefer moccasins. Not much difference.
I grew up running on my toes, but changed to heel running in high school. It wasn't a positive switch, and by college had damaged my knees pretty badly. Switching back to toe running was a big help. I would love to try these shes.
Great hub! As a runner I too have seen others wearing these and have decided that it must be working for them. I am having a hard time getting past the looks of these shoes as they remind me of those "toe socks" that were popular a few years back-with one addition- a strap from a Mary Jane type shoe. Really?! :)
Hi steph, I'm one who can't get past the look of these shoes too. I have a sister-in-law who wears them and loves them but she too agrees they are ugly. Still, if you enjoy running and keeping fit, who cares what you wear??
Well, I really hope it's not a fad and that these become more popular. I saw a video about this sometime last year (about the benefits of running barefoot). I think it would solve a lot of health problems. Getting schools to accept these as good shoes for running track and whatnot, now that's another story. Great topic! Thumbs up, Steph.
Hi, fascinating! I love the toes, but I am not sure I could wear them, I have funny shaped feet! lol they are a bit like a ballet dancers, all ball, and tiny toes! but they do look comfortable, not sure about running in them though, cheers nell
I probably wouldn't wear them with an evening dress (though in my case I just might to get a laugh)....but interesting! I will have to check out a pair the next time I'm out at REI - I assume they must carry them or someone here in the Central Oregon mecca must!
Now you can be a confident expert on Barefoot Shoes. OK, maybe not an expert. But you should have something to bring to the table next time you join a discussion on Barefoot Shoes.
I recently heard about these so I was excited to see you write a hub about them so I could learn more about them. Great hub, very informative! They look really comfortable but I think that if you are running on a hard surface, you'd probably do damage to your joints and the balls and heels of your feet! I bet they would feel good though if you were running on a softer surface like dirt. Interesting concept for sure! What will they come up with next?!
Seems like a great idea to me, I prefer less shoe and more natural anyway - like no ties, no pants, er, you know what I mean. I can't wait to buy another set of Tivas (not as durable as people claim by the way) because I hate constricting my feet.
Personally, I can do without the barefoot shoe, but I have heard about people who go barefoot everywhere, and they have built up such callouses that it doesn't bother them.
They think it's healthy and actually say that it is better to step on a rusty nail barefoot because you react faster and with a shoe, you put your full weight down thereby forcing the nail in deeper.
I would try them, but the individual toe coverings are a little much.
I liked jogging and I choose the best shoes for my feet. Thanks for share about this. I always give attention related with health and sport. And I find this form your hub. Excellent and very well written. I love your presentation. All the video are amazing. Good work, Steph. I give my vote to you. Take care!
Prasetio
I run SHORT distances (7 miles or less) only in these shoes. They are not good for distance running. However, they do help build muscle in your feet and legs. In essence, they are the perfect type of shoes for speed work.
Looks awesome, I'm not sure about running out and about a city though, one broken bottle....
Very interesting article Steph! While reading the hub, I kept thinking about the additional places of friction that could occur with each toe being covered (more blisters). I was glad to see listed as one of the pros as well as cons, being the fact "that it fits like a glove."
Definitely agree with you, don't think this one is for me. Of course, we will know that it is a winner if all the athletes starts wearing them.:) Thx for sharing an informative story. Rating up!:)
Wow, what a good page and interesting new technology in footwear. I don't think I will be using them at all. I have a feeling that toes covered completely is just less likely to be broken. That's just my thinking though who know's. Voted up and useful. A.B.
You have covered this so well and it makes so much sense because we do tend to come down on our heels and do so much damage to our skeletal system.
I have worn Korean negative heel shoes that I bought in Seoul and they help me come down on the ball of my feet which not only has built muscles on the sides of my legs (yay!) - but allows me to walk on ice (like Korean people) something Americans cannot do without falling.
I even like the way these look! So clever - we were meant to go barefoot when you think about it.
Rated way up! Yay!
Very well written Steph, thank you for the review, I am going to give them a try as I love to run--I do agree that using barefoot shoes on a long distance run would be an oxy-marathon. =:)
Great hub with great info. A friend of mine has a pair of these and he loves them. Not sure about trying them for myself just yet :)
Hi Steph. I trained for and ran the NYC Marathon in Nike Frees. A little more cushioning than the Five Fingers. I felt great and had a great run!
Nice info and thanks for sharing.
I like running but like you I prefer to have some cushioning as I pound out that mileage on hard concrete. A very well written and highly informative hub. Thank you.
I just covered a half-marathon sponsored by the newspaper I freelance for and a friend, who is a runner, wore these for the race. She said she loved them. I'm not a runner but plan to try a couple 5ks this year.
I am not a runner, but if I were I would want to wear the more traditional padded running shoes. However, since I walk up to six miles a day I do prefer a light weight canvas shoe over a clunky walking shoe. I just want a bit more padding than the barefoot shoe has to offer.
Thanks for the great hub steph! I've been writing about CrossFit, any my instructor wears these, so I've been curious for about a month now. Everyone I know who wears them loves them. Maybe I'll cave and try a pair.
I love my Vibram KSO's, but did take some time to get used to them. I think there are some muscles in my feet that had been asleep for 20 years before I started wearing Vibrams for running. Now my arches seem higher and I'm pretty sure that's making my foot shorter, as I can fit into shoes a size smaller than I used to.
Have been wondering about these barefoot shoes...thanks!
If you have no objection I would like to link this hub to my shoe story hub.
I think that these five finger shoes are much too overpriced. With that being said, I have been starting to do the barefoot running, and I can run further, with less pain than when I was running with regular sneakers. Albeit, I'm not in the best of shape, but I was getting pains in the wrong places when I went out to run. Not a bit of it when I went barefoot, aside from very tender burning feet after. I've recently compromised a little, and bought a cheap pair of water shoes that were about $7.00, and that has helped my feet from blistering. Now the only obstacle is just building up my endurance, to make up for the lack of shape that I am in. Already though, running has been much more of a joy, then from what ever I was doing in the past.
Nice Hub. I actually do like the looks of these shoes. Today I was wearing my flops at the beach and they were rubbing my feet like sandpaper when I got sand in them. I also dislike when seaweed touches my feet it is a very unpleasant feeling. Thank you.
I bought a pair of the KSO version of these about three months ago. The majority of my work day I am stuck at a desk in front of a computer. I train Brazilian Jiu Jitsu, am an avid hiker/backpacker and I like climbing. I hurt my back deadlifting about a year ago and was layed up for about as long. Even once I started to feel better, I still had a nagging ache in my back after a hard practice or hike. After wearing these for the past three months now my back pain is gone, my legs feel stronger and in jiu jitsu I feel I have better balance. I just did a three day backpacking trip with them and had no problems depsite the distance and unlevel ground. I am a believer
Excellent hub. Very insightful, and informative.
Very interesting information.
I believe that the vibrams are most definitely a functional "shoe" to wear. Although i dont use them I seen many people use them. Ive even seen people run barefoot! I suppose though this only works for some people because the only time i ran barefoot i got hurt!!
The clunky running shoes that we all wear now really limit the strengthening of muscles and tendons in our feet. In that way, I think the vibrams are good in that they help work out those underused parts of our feet!
Thanks for the article, you put a lot of effort into it! Great job.
I've thought about trying these out, but I think they need a lot of bedding in time.
What a brilliant Hub. I was a runner in my youth and always ran barefoot. I now run at my gym in shoes and have noticed that my style is very different. I have a natural tendency to run on the side of my foot. I tend to throw my foot out and I think, after reading your hub, this is my style from my youth running barefooted. I knew there was something wrong running in shoes. I am going to get some barefoot shoes..I think this is great! thanks!
Steph, they don't look like they give much protection to the foot like normal running shoes would. Nice hub with loads of facts and props.Vote awesome ( Must have taken ages to put together).
Interesting hub. I have a seen a few of these and did not know what they were for! I wonder if they are recommended for just everyday use too? I wear my crocs everyday and they are kind of ugly but my feet LOVE them.
steph
After watching the slow motion YouTube video, it seems that barefoot shoes may lay increased street on your legs. It'd be tough to imagine wearing barefoot shoes on a daily run after being accustomed to heavily padded and well cushioned runners. Utility value does seem low for right now but I might end up ordering a pair for myself anyways!
Princesswithapen
I'm in a rural town in Tennessee and just saw a woman wearing a pair of these the other day. I must say, she attracted quite a bit of attention. So I came looking for more info.
Because they are...er, different looking, I don't know that I'm completely sold but the idea of less joint pain is definitely appealing.
Wow, thanks for the info. I saw a guy wearing a pair of these at the mall with his tight shirt....Priceless....i am currently doing distance runs too so I am not ready to try them.
Very good research but the fact of the matter remains- they are not pretty! I can't see them replacing any other footwear but, as a few people mentioned here, serious runners and sports fans may use them.
Steph, Carefully researched and well presented.
Back in the Midwest, I used to cross paths with a woman who went barefoot year-round, even in the height of winter, and winters were brutal! She said that her feet were never cold because her circulation is so great from the daily exercise of walking everywhere. She even used to walk onto frozen expanses of area lakes!
I do love to walk, run, or cycle barefoot from time to time; the feeling of freedom is incomparable, especially in contrast to the weighty feeling which inheres in most running shoes.
Another great informational hub for exercise enthusiasts as well as for armchair exercisers who are thinking about revitalizing their mobility.
Thanks for creating such an informative hub! Extremely well exeuted and useful too. Voted up
Honestly, there are many styles that do not look so silly. I have the women's pace glove by Merrell and absolutely love these shoes. They've changed everything about the way I move in the world.
Warning: They are extremely addicting! I want to buy more and more styles so I can save the pace gloves for running and nothing more.
Sure, it took some time to get my legs adjusted to the new style, but that was minimal. I already wear flats and shoes with little padding, so my legs were prepared for what was coming.
This is all coming from someone who has dropped 20 pounds, from 270 to 250, since January. I'm a heavy person and can do quite a bit of wear and tear on a short run. I can run every day with my barefoot shoes.
Oh, and we paid $60, brand new, on a military base.
































































drbj Level 8 Commenter 16 months ago
The shoes are strange looking, steph, but only time will tell if they are better for us than traditional running shoes.
And yes, I am curious, why are so many available on ebay?